Why oil and water separate | Club Charlie

A shaken salad dressing offers a small window into the different attractions between molecules.

Different kinds of attraction: Water molecules have slightly positive and negative regions, so they attract one another strongly. The molecules in cooking oil are largely nonpolar. Mixing them thoroughly with water would interrupt many favorable water-to-water contacts without replacing them with equally favorable contacts. The liquids therefore tend to form separate regions.

Why the oil sits above: Most cooking oils are less dense than water. Once separate layers form, the lighter oil layer usually floats above the water-rich layer. Density explains which layer is on top; it does not, by itself, explain why the liquids refuse to dissolve in each other.

A temporary cloudy mixture: Shaking breaks the oil into small droplets dispersed through the water. This is an emulsion, rather than a true solution. Left standing, many droplets merge and the layers return. Suitable emulsifiers can help keep droplets apart; that is why some dressings stay mixed longer than a simple combination of oil and vinegar.

Molecular attractions help determine whether liquids mix.

Density determines the order of the separate layers.

Shaking disperses droplets without dissolving the oil.

Polarity: An uneven distribution of electrical charge within a molecule.

Density: Mass contained in a given volume.

Emulsion: A mixture of droplets of one liquid dispersed in another.